Skip to Accessibility Tools Skip to Content Skip to Footer
Image shows four women in hospital gowns. Each has a different shadow numbered 1 through 4. The woman with the 4 shadow is shrugging and has a quizzical question mark above her, showing her uncertainty about whether she

Is there a Role for Primary Surgery in Stage IV Breast Cancer?

Breast cancer is the most common cancer in American women, excluding skin cancers. There is a 1 in 8 chance that a woman will develop breast cancer during her lifetime. While incidence rates are rising, death rates have dropped dramatically over the last 30 years.1

Breast cancer is generally treated either surgically or systemically, depending on the diagnosis. There are various kinds of breast cancer which respond differently to specific treatments. Over time, new treatments have been developed to target the underlying cause of specific cancers.

Stage IV breast cancer

Stage IV, also known as metastatic breast cancer, occurs when the disease has spread to one or more additional areas of the body, such as bones, liver, lungs, or brain. Spread often occurs through the lymph system or bloodstream. The typical treatment has been with systemic therapy.4

Systemic therapy treatment option

Drug treatment has been the primary approach for most women with Stage IV breast cancer. Hormone therapy, chemotherapy, and targeted drug treatment are generally prescribed alone or in combination to attack the cancer. Types of drugs used for stage IV breast cancer depend on the hormone receptor status and the HER2 status of the cancer.

Local treatment options

Surgery, like radiation, is considered a local treatment for stage IV breast cancer. Traditionally it has not been used for Stage IV Breast Cancer or has been performed after systemic therapies were used to shrink a tumor, allowing the tumor to be more easily surgically removed.2 But removing tumors is not considered a cure.

New studies suggest surgery is an option that may result in longer survival when considered alongside targeted therapy, and other standards of care. Study authors recognized the importance of analyzing the HER2 subsets and distinct therapies when making clinical recommendations.2,3

For women who have anti-human epidermal growth factor receptor HER2+ disease, systemic therapy has produced positive outcomes. HER2+ breast cancer is characterized by tumors that overproduce a specific molecule known as human epidermal growth factor receptor-2, or HER2. Herceptin is a drug used to treat HER2+ breast cancer. It has been used alone and in combination with other chemotherapy drugs.

In a recently published study out of California, investigators sought to look at the impact of primary tumor resection on survival in HER2+ stage IV breast cancer patients since the recognition of HER2 targeted therapies.2 They examined outcomes for 3,200 cases from the National Cancer Database, from the start of HER2 data collection in 2010 to 2012. Although prior study results have been variable, the most recent findings determined that women with metastatic HER2-positive breast cancer lived longer if they had surgery for the primary tumor.

The researchers identified and controlled for covariates, variables that were measured but not considered in the original outcomes. These covariates included age, ethnicity, and type of health insurance. This information, when analyzed in combination with outcomes, improved accuracy of the final analysis.

Conclusions

Surgery of the primary site in metastatic HER2+ breast cancer is associated with improved overall survival. With the surgery median overall survival (OS) was 25 months, as compared with 18 months for those that did not have surgery. To be sure, study results have been inconsistent. A large study from India showed no improved rate of survival with surgery, whereas one in Turkey found that surgery lowered the risk of premature death by a third.

When considering treatment strategies, doctors should discuss surgical options with their patients based on each patient’s specific evidence-based clinical makeup.2 Future studies of surgery for stage IV breast cancer will likely address issues related to effects timing has on different therapies.

Variables noted of those who had primary site HER2+ breast cancer surgery included being younger, at a lower income level, more likely to have private insurance or Medicare coverage, and treatment at a community cancer center. Other factors besides surgery associated with a longer survival included older age, Medicare coverage, and drug treatments with systemic agents. 3

  1. How common is breast cancer? Available at: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/breast-cancer/about/how-common-is-breast-cancer.html. Accessed 5.1.19
  2. Mudgway,R. Chavez de Paz Villanueva, C. The impact of primary tumor surgery on survival in HER2 positive stage IV breast cancer patients in the current era of targeted therapy Available at: https://www.abstractsonline.com/pp8/#!/6812/presentation/6349. Accessed 5.1.19
  3. Bankhead, C. Role for Primary Surgery in Stage IV Breast Ca? Available at: https://www.medpagetoday.com/meetingcoverage/aacr/79010. Accessed 5.1.19
  4. Treatment of Stage IV (Metastatic) Breast Cancer. Available at: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/breast-cancer/treatment/treatment-of-breast-cancer-by-stage/treatment-of-stage-iv-advanced-breast-cancer.html. Accessed 5.1.19

Comments

  • OneIntelligentAngel
    4 months ago

    How should errors in medical charts be handled? My OB-GYN chart has glaring errors — including specifying that I have “no cancer” and “no breast lump” when I told her my history of breast cancer, and her manual exam should have revealed the one-inch lump. The record also indicated that I’m “sexually active”, when I’m not, and 4 or 5 other errors.

    When I brought this to the attention of the office manager more than a year ago, the correction had still not been made by the time of the follow-up visit. With a lot on my hands just to manage the cancer, I’m shy about pursuing other matters like this, but I feel it should be done. What is the proper protocol or procedure for pursuing corrections of medical records? Has anyone else encountered this?

  • SumraAlvi moderator
    4 months ago

    Hi OneIntelligentAngel, thanks for your question it’s great to hear from you. This must be so frustrating and upsetting. Have you tried to speak your doctor directly about the errors? Maybe you could set up a time to review your medical records with them in-person. Or alternatively, you could also reach out directly to medical records office to request an update or correction. It may be helpful to help document your communication in writing with either your drs office or medical records. I hope this helps, I appreciate you being here. Feel free to keep us updated on your progress! Warmly, Sumra (AdvancedBreastCancer.net Team)

  • Poll